1

Hi,

Once the music is produced, well we usually want to do something with it. This is very broad, I know. Questions about copyright, lots of legal forms, branding, promotion, sites to advertise on, iTunes, etc.

Is it appropriate? I would argue so. It would also bring more activity to the site.

Best,

(additional edit: since the beta stackexchange site of Area51 has a musician's site coming up and strong with many commited members joining, and their site EXPLICTLY says no discussion about the music industry or publishing etc., it has to be discussed somewhere. And most professionals in AR&R work for publishing companies/studios anyways. They have valuable information. Why need another site for something with such a strong overlap. Good recording means good publishing. Big bands, small ones trying to get up, want to record and publish their music. This topic does not fit into guitars, music/musicians, so why not here. Yes, it may bogg the site down with ego maniacs stressed with contracts and legalities, but then it means that another stackexchange site does not need to be made. And there is quite a bit of overlap between some sites like Ubuntu->Linux/Unix->StackOverflow->SuperUser already.)

2

Although this has not been discussed between us (mods), I am a bit reluctant with approving it. The subject basically fits within our community, the real issue with this kind of questions is that the right answer is dependent on the country that you're in.

A general rule of thumb if you want to figure out whether a question fits in here, is 'do you expect many people here that know the answer? Or are there communities (especially within SE) that would be more appropriate?'

Last, if you do decide to ask this question on the board, be both complete and general in your question. Include your country / state, the exact music that your question is about etc.

1
  • thanks! perfect answer, makes sense as well, and is fair.
    – Vass
    Mar 14 '11 at 16:33
1

It's not disallowed by the /faq

http://audio.stackexchange.com/faq

However I think the rest of the community should weigh in -- how closely is this related to the general topic of "Audio Recording and Production?"

4
  • but... the FAQ does not refer explicitly to the publishing of music or the music industry part of production. why is it out of scope?
    – Vass
    Mar 10 '11 at 11:56
  • 1
    I think it generally fits the community, but is highly country-specific and therefore possibly inappropriate.
    – Pelle
    Mar 14 '11 at 8:32
  • The more I think about it, the more I think that it does fit, but only in a general sense - the same way questions about software business and law show occasionally show up on SO and Programmers. Mar 24 '11 at 15:02
  • I think it would dilute the site a bit too much, at least while it's still a young site that's trying to find a voice. May 2 '11 at 4:44
1

I think we need to consider the upcoming might-happen merge with the Video proposal; would that mean we'd be allowing question about film distribution? Getting into Sundance? Youtube social marketing? I'd like to cautiously defer this until the fallout from that merge settles, (or until the merge clearly isn't happening.)

1

I don't see why not. Most people who go to the trouble of making a recording do so with the intention of sharing it with others in some way, so as long as the questions were not "too localized", I think the community would find it interesting to have the occasional question like:

  • Where can I host my music online for people to listen to for free?
  • Where can I host my music online for people to buy?
  • How do I get my song onto iTunes?
  • I made a cover of someone else's song, what are the legal implications?

It seems ironic to rule out questions on this aspect of audio recording and production, while at the same time having several proposals trying to broaden the "scope" of this site.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .